From Frontier to Emerging: Does Market Reclassification Matter?

29 January, 2012
read < 1 minute

DIFC Economic Note 19, titled From Frontier to Emerging – Does Market Reclassification Matter?, discusses and compares the market classification criteria and methodology used by the various index providers, including MSCI, noting the similarities and differences. MSCI have indicated that the UAE and Qatar are being considered for re-classification from Frontier to Emerging market status, subject to a number of reforms. Evidence on the effects of reclassifications in both developed and developing economies is studied in this paper and we find that while MSCI have undertaken some 14 reclassifications over the years, six of them have been downgrades while there have been no reclassification from Frontier to Emerging, yet.

Using past examples of classification changes, this paper examines the short- and long-term impacts of the reclassification – including an empirical analysis of the effects on markets returns of the classification of Egypt and Morocco as emerging markets. Our results indicate that the initial announcement of a potential reclassification leads to an “overshooting” with investors speculatively bidding up securities prices and returns prior to the actual reclassification event, leading to almost no impact post-reclassification. Additionally, too much emphasis is placed on a potential market reclassification, with many forgetting that reclassifications are best viewed as signaling a confirmation of policy reforms and changes in market conditions, which trigger the reclassification. Thus, there is an identification effect whereby improved market conditions, which are a result of policy actions and reforms (leading to a reclassification), could empirically be attributable to the reclassification itself.

Read Next

TV and radio

Bloomberg Daybreak Middle East Interview, 28 Nov 2022

Aathira Prasad joined Yousef Gamal El-Din  on 28th of November, 2022 as part of the

29 November, 2022

Reports & papers

“The Gulf Falcons Report”, prepared for the Abu Dhabi Finance Week, 14 Nov 2022

“The Gulf Falcons Report” (click to download) was prepared by Nasser Saidi & Associates (commissioned

15 November, 2022

TV and radio

Bloomberg Daybreak Middle East Interview, 14 Oct 2022

Aathira Prasad joined Manus Cranny on 14th of October, 2022 as part of the Bloomberg

15 October, 2022